Repair or Replace · Homeowners with a broken water heater, AC, furnace or roof
Fix it, or buy a new one?
- You put in
- What broke, how old it is, the repair quote, and a replacement quote if you have one.
- You get
- A repair-or-replace call, with the reason: its expected life and how the repair compares to new.
Free.
What you type stays on this device. This is a check, not tax or legal advice.
How it works
- What broke and how old it is.
- The repair quote, and a replacement quote if you have one.
- The call: repair or replace, and why.
Questions
How long should these last?
Tank water heaters 6 to 12 years, central air 7 to 15, furnaces 15 to 25, shingle roofs about 20 to 30 (less in hot, hail-prone places). From the home inspectors' life expectancy chart.
What's the rule?
Replace when the repair is half the price of new or more. Past its expected life, replace unless the repair is small. Inside it, repair if it's under a quarter of new.
Does insurance or a warranty change it?
Yes. Storm damage to a roof is often an insurance claim, and a home warranty may pay for the repair or the replacement. Check those first.
If the check doesn't help, email within 7 days for your money back. No account needed for the free check. Questions or something wrong? Tell us; every message is read.